A Question.

I just want to make something clear:
Here's a possible scenario-

I have Honest in my hand.
My enemy controls Doomcaliber Knight.
He attacks my Light type monster with Doom and I discard Honest.
Will Doom's effect activate and negate Honest's effect, or not?

Personally, I believe Doom's effect doesn't apply on Honest's for some reasons.


Any ideas?

Quote :

If a battling monster is removed from the field before Damage Calculation is performed, then you do not perform Damage Calculation. Thus, if the effect of "Honest" is activated during Damage Calculation when "Doomcaliber Knight" battles a LIGHT monster and the effect of "Doomcaliber Knight" is Chained to the effect of "Honest", then the battling "Doomcaliber Knight" is not face-up on the field, so Damage Calculation is not performed.[8]

so Doomcaliber negates eff activations that happen in the hand? does it work on effects that activate when removed from play and such as well?

Whenever a monster's effect activates.

It doesn't matter where it is.

Hannibal wrote:

Quote :

If a battling monster is removed from the field before Damage Calculation is performed, then you do not perform Damage Calculation. Thus, if the effect of "Honest" is activated during Damage Calculation when "Doomcaliber Knight" battles a LIGHT monster and the effect of "Doomcaliber Knight" is Chained to the effect of "Honest", then the battling "Doomcaliber Knight" is not face-up on the field, so Damage Calculation is not performed.[8]

Alright,
Thank you Hannibal.

Admins- You may close this topic.

another question relates:

Honest's eff activates when it s in damage calculation. However, quote from u sed, doom negated honest and sent to grave, so damage calcultion doesnt apply.... doesnt tat mean Honest's eff cant be activated ??? since thre isnt any damage calculation @_@

To your question yes Honest can still be activated. It's just that once Doomcaliber Knight negates the effect the battle never takes place, and damage calculation is never processed. The only thing that would happen is no battle and both go to the graveyard.

It's seems dumb though because you can't destroy and send to the graveyard an Honest that was already sent there, but I think the effect negation still applies.

to confirm... yes it does negate, coz doom's eff s compulsory, doom negates honest when it s ABOUT to activate !!! ^^jst want to make sure

So, this is resolved.

-Closed-