A stupid questions about Solemn Judgment

ElenFNX wrote:

If i activate Solemn Judgment, and my opponent negate it, does i still pay the cost? And can i negate effect of a monster with Solemn Judgment? I know that are stupid questions, but i'm not 100% shure for the answer...

1st: No,you don't pay the cost of Solemn if it's negated.Because if anyone uses Dark Bribe on Solemn,his effect is Negated,this means it will not activate.

2nd: No,you can't negate the effect of a monster.The card's effect says only "Spell,Trap" and "Summoned Monster".But if in case you summon a monarch,or Jinzo and others,and the opponent activated Solemn Judgement,the monster's effect isn't activated,because in this case,the monster don't touch the field.

Additional:

It's strange,but with Solemn you can negate even Jinzo,when it's summoned.

Hope i helped

Yes you do pay the cost of Solemn Judgement if it's negated.

You indeed lose the LPs. Paying half of your Life Points is a cost to activate Solemn Judgment, not part of the effect. You can check the rulebook and you'll see that costs aren't refunded when their card is negated.

Battosai is correct, even if Solemn Judgment is negated, you still have to pay half your LP because it is a cost just like how you activate Lightning Vortex, even if it is negated you must still discard a card first.

Nope, SJ can't negate effects.

Since these questions have been answered...

-Closed-

Oh, and there are no stupid questions.